Guidebook for Montauk
Food Scene
One of our favorite restaurants. Great for a sunset beach cocktail and excellent food.
49 residents recomanen
Navy Beach
16 Navy RdOne of our favorite restaurants. Great for a sunset beach cocktail and excellent food.
Ruschmeyer's
161 2nd House RdAnother excellent restaurant. Lots of fun and good food.
The Surf Lodge
183 Edgemere StGreat venue for cocktails and people spotting
A Montauk staple at the tip of the Island. Great place for a sunset cocktail and a great fish market. Good for families.
67 residents recomanen
Gosman's
500 W Lake DrA Montauk staple at the tip of the Island. Great place for a sunset cocktail and a great fish market. Good for families.
The best place for sandwiches and breakfast on the go. Great when you get hungry at the town beach.
20 residents recomanen
Joni's
South Elmwood AvenueThe best place for sandwiches and breakfast on the go. Great when you get hungry at the town beach.
Vintage Montauk Lobster shack right on the water. No frills but great views and good simple fish dishes.
77 residents recomanen
Duryea's Lobster Deck
65 Tuthill RdVintage Montauk Lobster shack right on the water. No frills but great views and good simple fish dishes.
A staple and a classic. Great Lobster and fish sandwiches.
91 residents recomanen
Lobster Roll aka LUNCH
1980 Montauk HighwayA staple and a classic. Great Lobster and fish sandwiches.
Primavera Pizza
54 S Erie AveGreat take out pizza!
Harvest On Fort Pond
11 S Emery StAnother nice lakeside restaurant. Family style portions.
Essentials
IGA
95 S Emerson AveThe closest place to get the basics and not have to pay Hamptons prices!
Best place to buy fresh fish as well as higher quality produce.
22 residents recomanen
Gosman's Retail Fish Market
484 W Lake DrBest place to buy fresh fish as well as higher quality produce.
Montauk Liquors & Wines Inc.
29 The PlazaBest place to buy the essentials.
Drinks & Nightlife
Great hotel with a fun bar and weekend music etc... also a good spot to get a massage.
15 residents recomanen
Sole East Resort
90 2nd House RdGreat hotel with a fun bar and weekend music etc... also a good spot to get a massage.
Sightseeing
If you want to check out the local surf... this is the spot. But be careful... there's limited parking so better to get dropped off or walk from the street.
79 residents recomanen
Ditch Plains Beach
18 Ditch Plains RdIf you want to check out the local surf... this is the spot. But be careful... there's limited parking so better to get dropped off or walk from the street.